Lewis observes in the abolition of man, across different religions. The american republic will endure until the day congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the publics money. My purpose is to examine both tocqueville and bellah to illuminate the problem of democratic individualism. This fourvolume book is brimming with insights and sharp observations. The second reason is that there was no democratic revolution in. He traveled to america in the 1830s to discover the reasons for the incredible success of this new nation.
One way in which he stood out in nineteenthcentury france was his attitude towards religion. The first english translation, by henry reeve and titled democracy in america a, was published in new york in 1838. Although not always a consistent thinker, he stands squarely in the classical liberal tradition of understanding the capacity of society to self organize in the absence of a controlling central state. As democracy in america revealed, tocqueville believed that equality was the great political and social idea of his era, and he thought that the united states offered the most advanced example of equality in action. Such shared beliefs were held across the various christian denominations in tocquevilles america and are even held, as c. Relive their historic journey at this cspan produced website. According to tocqueville, american religion teaches, as the puritan founder john winthrop put it, that freedom means the freedom to do only what is just.
Of these, the antireligious passion was the first to be kindled and the last to be extinguished. The problem of democratic individualism the russell kirk. Tocquevilles democratic curiosity about democracy permeates his great book, which was published in two volumes, in 1835 and 1840. The principal established religious sects in north america are the methodists. He published his observations in his classic twovolume work, democracy in america. New york historical society quarterly 61 januaryapril 1977. Here, olivier zunz goes into further detail on the nineteenthcentury french scholars thoughts on associations and philanthropy. Christianity as philosophy luk sanders royal higher institute for defence, brussels, belgium. He had a private tutor, the abbe lesueur, until high school, and then attended high. These are doctrines of faith, since for tocqueville religion means revealed religion, not a rational or natural religion, such as deism, which other liberals in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries had proposed to replace revealed religion. In a subsequent post, emma saundershastings asks whether american philanthropy today is democratic. Tension between traditional and modern values dominated tocquevilles life and writings. Today, americans often think of individualism as working in tandem with liberty, but tocqueville not only saw these two ideals as diametrically opposed, he also believed that individualism.
For the purposes of discussing tocqueville, individualism could be briefly defined as a focus on individual aims and beliefs over those of the collective. Evangelical theological faculty, leuven, belgium correspondence luk. First to raise topics of american practicality over theory, the industrial. After traveling across the country and conducting more than two hundred interviews with americans of all classes, he returned to france to meditate on what he had seen and heard. This serves as a vital check on the individualistic impulse of the democratic man and offers a fixed moral orientation. In the book, tocqueville examines the democratic revolution. Tocqueville thought that religion and he was favorable to almost any kind of religion was essential to democracy for many reasons. One of the noblest enterprises of our time, he added, would be to show that morality, religion and order do not need to be opposed to liberty and the equality of men before the law. The french revolution, tocqueville thought, saw two great passions at work. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Motivated by his love of liberty and human dignity, his democracy in america has been called one of the wisest works of modern thought, that for understanding and preserving liberty, the intelligent american reader can find no better guide. Probably the most important one was that tocqueville thought that organized religion was the only possible longterm counterweight to some of the main threats democracy faced. Openeyed, restless, theoretical but also pragmatic, interested. Democracy is defined in websters encyclopedic dictionary as. A the common good is far more important than an individuals pursuit of success. But in the end, they learned a whole heap about american political culture. Tocqueville on christianity and american democracy the. He was particularly impressed by the role of freedom of association in underpinning collective action, freedom of the press in serving as a watchdog for the people, and religious freedom in sustaining the beliefs that define the american character. Tocqueville thus teaches us that religionor the right kind of religionis necessary to human greatness within democracy. The european revolution and correspondence with gobineau, edited by john lukacs. B american exceptionalism was tocquevilles explanation as to why the united states was a superior nation. He visited the united states in 1831 and wrote one of the most famous commentaries on american life and culture, democracy in america.
For older, but still useful, accounts, compare dorothy s. Some of his most intriguing comments concern women, the. Tocquevilles father was a royalist prefect from normandy who supported the bourbon monarchy, his greatgrandfather was a liberal aristocrat killed in the french revolution, and his mother was a devout roman. T ocqueville argues, and bellah agrees, that democratization dissolves the ties or duties which link human beings to one anotherthose that constitute the. Tocqueville on the naturalness of religious belief law. Its title translates as on democracy in america, but english translations are usually simply entitled democracy in america. It fights against materialism as well as the view that man is. But what happens when religion also becomes preoccupied with equality. The first volume of tocquevilles twovolume work was immediately popular throughout europe. He is best known for his works democracy in america appearing in two volumes, 1835 and 1840 and the old regime and the revolution 1856. His older brothers were named hippolyte and edouard. His book written in two parts in 1835 and 1840 discusses the advantages of democracy and consequences of the majoritys unlimited power. Throughout his analysis of america, he draws many outlandish and interesting. He was a white french journalist and abolitionist writer.
746 901 1436 997 464 243 487 56 1354 713 122 1580 508 141 504 978 238 451 892 927 1056 1320 613 902 1048 848 1043 945 1120 365 862 1140 687 146 967 1353 1348 695 1317 1071